Assessing americas war on terror carnegie endowment. Jean bethke elshtain advocates just war in times of crisis and mounts a reasoned attack against the antiwar contingent in american intellectual life. Repeating history in the war on terrorism david cole. In the past, the enemy has always been a hostile country. In my opinion, the war on terror like all other wars is irrational and the mainstream media is not playing an objective role in getting the average american involved in the matter. It is a disappointment in the sense that those looking for a sustained and informative treatment of the struggle against terrorism illuminated by the just war tradition will be let down a conclusion confirmed for me by both civilians and soldiers one responsible for teaching the just war tradition to other soldiers. The war on terror, its impact on the sovereignty of states, and its implications for human rights and civil liberties lecture delivered at the international ecumenical conference on terrorism in a globalized world organized by the national council of churches in the philippines nccp, the world council of.
The war against terrorism aspired to reduce to zero the number of attacks on american territory no matter how many attacks that would require america to conduct, and provoke, abroad. Jan 15, 2009 the foreign secretary, david miliband, today argues that the use of the war on terror as a western rallying cry since the september 11 attacks has been a mistake that may have caused more harm. A society that embraces war without end eventually stops recognizing that its initial adrenaline response is abnormal. Our founders and supporters are united by a common interest in fostering a strong british, european, and. Clausewitz defined war as a political act between two parties with irreconcilable political differences. The american idea of a war against terror, and the european notion of confronting a global terrorist threat, have together merged with a discourse on. Review of jean bethke elshtain, just war against terror. The burden of american power in a violent world jean bethke elshtain on. The burden of american power in a violent world reprint by elshtain, jean isbn. Some common elements of most definitions of terrorism are highlighted, including a discussion of the debatable criteria and why. Reconstructing just war theory after september 11, international politics, 42, march 2005.
War on terror was a mistake, says miliband politics the. Role of pakistan in war against terrorism with particular emphasis. War, terrorism, and the war on terror rutgers university. In 1958, in the midst of the cold war, yale law professor ralph brown opened his comprehensive study of the federal governments loyalty and security program by claim. The fundamental issues from a just war perspective, there are at least two issues to be addressed at the outset when considering terrorism. The second is what responsibility legitimate political authorities have with regards to terrorism. Thanassis cambanis, archive we are the war on terror, and.
Analysts examined all stories about three main topics in the medias coverage of the war on terror. This is a problematic issue because there is no agreement about what terrorism actually is. If, on the other hand, the victors have won a just war against an aggressor, locke argues that the victors right does not extend to the aggressive nations civilian population, but that it does extend to all those engaged in the aggression and that it extends absolutely. The laws of war are not direct adaptations of the principles of morality to the circumstances of war. Samuel huntington, the clash of civilizations and the remaking of world order simon and schuster, 1998. Applying the just war tradition suggests that in order to justify a war on terrorism, we need to know exactly who the terrorists are and whether they have given us just cause for war. The threat from boko haram and ansaru the henry jackson society 3 the henry jackson society the henry jackson society is a crosspartisan thinktank based in london. Just a few days ago, prime minister ecevit announced that turkey would join the coalition against terror, very enthusiastically, even more so than others.
Iraq claimed that kuwait was a long time province from the 1800s and early 1900s, whose lands belonged under control of iraq, a. The burden of american power in a violent world new york. Bush first used the expression war on terror on september 20, 2001, in an address to a joint session of congress, following the. Nov 30, 2015 islamic militants couldnt ask for a better recruiting gift.
Jun 04, 2004 though he acknowledges the differences that make applying just war theory on new wars, and specifically the war on terror he establishes a clear case of evaluation that shows that while the goals, motivations and justifications of states in the war on terror are just, their implementation of the war will remain to be seen as so. Though he acknowledges the differences that make applying just war theory on new wars, and specifically the war on terror he establishes a clear case of evaluation that shows that while the goals, motivations and justifications of states in the war on terror are just, their implementation of the war will remain to be seen as so. The war against terrorism on august 2nd 1990, iraq invaded the small oil rich country of kuwait on its southeastern border. In her latest book, just war against terror, jean bethke elshtain argues for a new strategic paradigm in american foreign policy in the aftermath of the attacks of september 11. Cair claims that the war on terrorism is a war on islam. Just war theory and the war on terror the ornery american. Either professor elshtain has not heard of my lai, watergate, irancontra, or other evidence of american depravity, or she has somehow concluded that these and other failings, when measured against the campaign against human slavery that was the union cause in the civil war, the defeat of nazism, and the 40year defense against communism.
Although war everywhere, against every injustice, is neither plausible nor likely, confronting amoral, brutal states such as the talibans afghanistan or saddam husseins iraq. Advocating an ethic of responsibility, elshtain forces us to ask tough questions not only about the nature of terrorism, but about ourselves. Naturally, the 2002 nes included an extensive set of questions relevant to this new world. One of the standard tricks theology teachers used to play in prevatican ii catholic schools was the dilemma of the lesser of two evils. In reference to a just war, it also describes the limitations and the differences between jus ad bellum and jus in bello and evaluates whether the recent war in. The main purpose they are intended to serve is the separation of war from other human activities. The first example came from president bushs statement to the united states on the evening of september 11, when he stated, america. And despite him using these expressions as well as war against terror almost interchangeably. A war against all those who seek to export terror, and a war against those governments that support or shelter them. Iraq claimed that kuwait was a long time province from the 1800s and early 1900s, whose lands belonged under control of iraq, a socalled province. The us is fighting against isis alongside iran and the iranianbacked baghdad government in iraq, and fighting in syria against isis alongside sort of the iranianbacked and usopposed government in damascus.
Oct 24, 2001 just a few days ago, prime minister ecevit announced that turkey would join the coalition against terror, very enthusiastically, even more so than others. The first is whether or not terroristic violence is moral. Washington the united states has about 15,475 combat troops deployed to fight the war on terror, about 2,650 more troops than six months ago. Although war everywhere, against every injustice, is neither plausible nor likely, confronting amoral, brutal states such as the talibans afghanistan or saddam husseins iraq is a viable option in the just war tradition. From a just war perspective, there are at least two issues to be addressed at the outset when considering terrorism. Terror in 2005, she merges both concepts by depicting the. Essay on the war against terrorism 976 words bartleby. The same goes for stepping up military action against isis. Just as the cold war ended only when one side essentially gave up on a bankrupt ideology, the battle against islamist terrorism will be won when the ideology that underpins. The alliance helped pakistan to overcome the sanctions, to get economic as well. Find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Joining the us led coalition in the war against terrorism has many short and long term repercussions for pakistan.
The foreign secretary, david miliband, today argues that the use of the war on terror as a western rallying cry since the september 11 attacks has been a. War, terrorism, and the war on terror 5 jeff mcmahan of war are different from those that govern the use of violence in other contexts, that the prohibition of killing the innocent can be overridden in order to destroy a military target as a means of advancing a just cause but not in order to terrorize people as a. Why a war on terrorism will generate yet more terrorism. But today its ideas and methods are predominant among jihadis because of the prestige and publicity it. How the united states justified its war on terrorism. Jun 26, 2008 either professor elshtain has not heard of my lai, watergate, irancontra, or other evidence of american depravity, or she has somehow concluded that these and other failings, when measured against the campaign against human slavery that was the union cause in the civil war, the defeat of nazism, and the 40year defense against communism. Just war theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy. It appears that the terms war on terror and war against terror were coined shortly after the september 11, 2001, attacks. It began in response to an unprovoked attack by those who threaten the security of free societies, it continued with proportionality and discrimination, and it works toward a world of peace and stability, even at the cost of many lives and much treasure. I begin by asking whether all terrorism is unjust and whether or not terrorism provides a just cause for war in all circumstances.
It began in response to an unprovoked attack by those who threaten the security of free societies, it continued with proportionality and discrimination, and it works toward a world of peace and stability, even at the cost. The war on terror, by satisfying the criteria presented, is a just war, if one is of the opinion that any war can be just. To withstand the enemies of freedom and democracy is both a right and an obligation. War, terrorism, and the war on terror 5 jeff mcmahan of war are different from those that govern the use of violence in other contexts, that the prohibition of killing the innocent can be overridden in order to destroy a military target as a means of advancing a just cause but not in order to terrorize people as a means of. Justwar theorist jean bethke elshtain says the question isnt whether to confront systematic terroristic violence, but how. Therefore a just war against terrorism is in order, and one does not have to have grave moral misgivings about it.
The author r obert satloff resumed his post as executive director of the washington institute for near east policy in july 2004 after more than two years living in morocco. Deaths at the time of conflict are just one element. The author is to be commended for reminding us of these truths, because too many western apologists for terrorism and radical islam are at work. It could simply mean the merger of the two phenomena, i. Jean bethke elshtain advocates just war in times of crisis and mounts a reasoned attack against the anti war contingent in american intellectual life. Michael ignatieffs the lesser evil offers a provocative complement to elshtains primer on the application of just war theory to terrorism. A week later he referred to a war on terrorismbush, 2001f and two days later, the expression changed from a war on terrorism to a war on terror bush, 2001g. In a just war, a sovereign nation is repelling an unjust aggressor who is inflicting the grave and lasting harm on the nation.
Just war, ethics, and terror central intelligence agency. Pdf war against terrorism and its repercussions for pakistan. War and terrorism have a terrible and longlasting impact on huge numbers of people. The burden of american power in a violent world, new york. Jb elshtain, international justice as equal regard and the use of force, ethics and international affairs, 17, 2003b, pp 6375. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Pdf joining the us led coalition in the war against terrorism has many short and long term. We are at war with a specific network, alqaeda, and its terrorist affiliates who support efforts to attack the united states, our allies, and partners.
Clausewitz defined war as a political act between two. Another part of the propaganda is to merge a future war against iran with the heroic memories of the sixday war nearly 45 years ago, as excia analyst ray mcgovern notes. Request pdf on sep 1, 2004, gerd oberleitner and others published a just war against terror. War, terrorism, and the war on terror 17 jeff mcmahan. Islamic militants couldnt ask for a better recruiting gift. Pakistan can fight the war against terrorism in its tribal areas effectively with the. Review of just war against terror by jean bethke elshtain elca. The united states has waged this war on terrorism against the backdrop of more tradi.
1477 28 1534 817 1104 1620 1542 1306 1224 332 1064 1642 531 416 1335 1214 1350 1017 1023 1206 120 848 855 756 1127 470 461 873 250 994 175 1049